ZIP Codes Where Buyers Pay Full Asking Price

Homebuyers in Indiana’s largest metro areas are still facing tight competition — especially in certain ZIP codes where sellers are consistently getting close to asking price. We took a look at the latest 3-week average for percent of list price received and picked out the ZIP codes with the highest percentages in each major metro.

Indianapolis

In the state’s largest housing market, ZIP 46220 (which includes parts of Broad Ripple and Meridian-Kessler) leads the way with homes selling for 99.4% of list price on average. Despite broader cooling trends, demand here remains strong thanks to walkability, charm, and location.

Fort Wayne

In northeast Indiana, ZIP 46825 tops the charts, with homes selling for 99.3% of list. This area offers a suburban feel with quick access to downtown and is popular with young families and professionals.

South Bend

Up north, ZIP 46530 (Granger) is red-hot, with a 99.7% average — one of the highest in the state. This area has seen consistent demand due to its schools, suburban character, and proximity to Notre Dame.

Lafayette

Home to Purdue University, ZIP 47906 takes the crown, with homes selling for 99.9% of list price. University-driven demand and limited supply have kept prices strong.

Evansville

In southwest Indiana, ZIP 47630 (Newburgh) leads with a 97.6% average. While slightly lower than other metros, it still signals a healthy market with strong seller leverage.

Across the state, these ZIP codes stand out not just for their price performance, but for the consistent appeal they offer to buyers. Whether it’s walkable neighborhoods or growing job markets, these markets are staying competitive — and sellers are reaping the rewards.